Diversity, equity and inclusion in publishing at Elsevier: an editor guide
At Elsevier, we promote and advance diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) throughout the research and publishing process, in collaboration with our editors, society partners, the research community and other publishers, via the joint community for action on inclusion and diversity in publishing se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana.
DEI protects against gaps and biases, minimizes confirmation bias, and promotes innovation and development; it is crucial for rigor, quality, and progress in science. It benefits not only individuals, by supporting every person to advance and excel, but also ensures more equitable and impactful research outcomes for society as a whole.
"We know inclusion is the right thing to do. Today's researchers are addressing the most pressing challenges facing humanity. The only way to make a lasting impact is by harnessing the full contribution of every brilliant researcher, whoever they are. Inclusion and diversity are critical for science and innovation."
KB
Kumsal Bayazit
Directora ejecutiva en Elsevier
At Elsevier, our approach to advancing DEI throughout the research and publishing is collaborative and evidence-based.
We undertake a range of activities to support inclusion and diversity in science. Our March 2022 Inclusion & Diversity Advisory Board Report summarized our progress during the two years since the Board's inception.
Processes & tools
We innovate our processes, workflows and tools to support DEI throughout the publishing process.
Avoiding publication bias
Initiatives such as Registered Reports and Results Masked Review aim for work to be judged on the merits of the research question and methodology, not the findings.
Registered Reports requires authors to submit and commit to their protocols before experiments are conducted. The journal then accepts the paper in principle, based on whether editors believe the protocol has merit, and commits to publishing the research regardless of the results.
With Results Masked Review, the experiments have already taken place, but the reviewers are first sent the paper with the results masked.
Both models seek to prevent publication bias and enhance transparency, thereby ensuring that results aren't skewed in pursuit of publication.
Inclusive peer review
Using diverse sources to identify suitable reviewers helps to diversify the candidates who are invited to review or join journal's reviewer communities. In support of this, we provide you with a selection of tools se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana, including Elsevier's "Find Reviewers using Scopus" se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana in Editorial Manager.
Best practice
We strive to raise awareness and understanding, and to encourage adoption of best practice (including through policies), in pursuit of DEI.
Self-reporting diversity data in Editorial Manager
We pursue an evidence-based approach to advancing DEI. In line with this, we are inviting editors, reviewers and authors to optionally self-report their diversity data in Editorial Manager. The gender identity, race and ethnicity (GRE) schemas used as part of this are those developed collaboratively across publishers se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana, led by Elsevier's Dr Holly Falk-Krzesinski, and endorsed in April 2022 se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana. The self-reported data will enable us to put in place actions, set goals and measure progress to improve diversity across journal editorial processes and drive greater equity in publishing and research more broadly.
Editorial team diversity
In 2016, we began engaging editors on the importance of gender-balanced editorial teams and we continue this dialogue today, for example, evaluating how we support women researchers to advance into editorial roles and seeking to learn what more we can do.
We work closely with our editors to promote transparency about editorial team diversity, and accountability to our communities about ambitions to further DEI. All Elsevier journals display the geographical breakdown of Editorial Boards on their journal homepages, and over 1,300 titles display self-reported gender data. Around 75% of Elsevier journals have published pledges on their journal homepages committing to improve diversity in their editorial teams with defined objectives.
Example of self-reported editorial gender identities on the journal homepage of an Elsevier neuroscience journal.
Training and guidance in your role
As an editor, together with society partners and publishers, you play a crucial role in advancing DEI in the journal and community you serve. Our Editor Essentials module on inclusion and diversity se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana provides you with practical actions to advance inclusion and diversity among your journal’s Editorial Board, reviewers and authors.
Additionally, we took a deep dive into inclusive peer review in September 2021, publishing a four-part article series. The series covers the importance of inclusive peer review and best practice for you to adopt:
Please continue to refer to Editor Essentials se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana on Elsevier Researcher Academy for the latest information and insights to support you.
Training and guidance for other roles
We work to provide new and aspiring reviewers with a thorough grounding in the principles and practice of refereeing via our certified peer reviewer course se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana (a Chinese language version is also available). From here they are signposted to the Reviewer Hub where they can volunteer to review se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana for relevant journals. This plays an important role in making reviewing more inclusive.
Similarly, we continuously review and enhance guidance to provide authors with the most up-to-date advice on how to promote inclusion and diversity in their research and publication practices. Our Researcher Academy inclusion and diversity modules se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana and journals’ guides for authors are key sources of information. Our guides for authors advise on the use of inclusive language, discussed further in this Authors’ Update article on using language to empower.
In 2023, Elsevier, Cell Press and the Lancet incorporated the Sex and Gender Equity in Research (SAGER) guidelines se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana into their information for authors, using these guidelines to develop a dedicated section on reporting sex- and gender-based analyses. Researchers can now find these guidelines in all Cell Press se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana journals, including some of its society partner journals; The Lancet se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana journals; and more than 2,300 Elsevier se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana journals. This effort aims to improve not only DEI within research, but to enhance the accuracy and integrity of the research we publish. You can read more here.
Avoiding unconscious bias
Several organizations se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana and groups se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana, Elsevier among them se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana, are making conscious efforts to tackle unconscious bias which, if left unchecked, can risk negatively impacting the publication of good research. This has led to the creation of a number of resources which can be employed to identify and combat unconscious bias or to reduce the likelihood of it affecting the peer review and academic publishing process, summarized in this article exploring unconscious bias, and on our dedicated unconscious bias page.
Inclusive name change policy
Elsevier’s trans-inclusive policy for author name changes allows transgender authors, and other authors who need to change their name privately, e.g., for reasons of personal safety, to update their name on previously published papers invisibly, i.e., with a resupply and no erratum / corrigendum. This policy, which is aligned with industry best practice se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana, enables us to help protect authors’ privacy and safety, while still safeguarding the scholarly record.
Your first step
I want to get involved, where should I start?
If you have not already done so, please view our Researcher Academy inclusion and diversity modules se abre en una nueva pestaña/ventana. We encourage you to work with your collaborators and co-authors to discuss how to advance DEI in your research and writing practice.